Post Perksby Uppercase
All posts

Black Friday

How to Turn Black Friday Shoppers Into Repeat Customers (Before They Forget You)

By Liz Chan4 min read

How to Turn Black Friday Shoppers Into Repeat Customers (Before They Forget You)

It’s coming. The biggest sales event of the year is almost here, and you’re pouring money into it, competing with every other online store and big-box retailer for the same shoppers. You finally get them to buy. And then what?

What are you doing to make them come back for their holiday shopping, and long after?

For most stores, the answer is “not much.” That’s a lot of money left on the table.

The Black Friday problem nobody talks about

Black Friday and Cyber Monday bring in a flood of first-time customers, but they’re also when it costs the most to win them. Ad prices climb, discounts get deeper, and margins get thinner.

Most of those customers never come back. Research from Uptain, which studied more than 3,000 online stores, found that around 85% of shoppers buy only once. So you pay the highest price of the year to win a customer, and most of the time, that first order is the only one you’ll get.

The good news is that the hardest part, getting them to buy, is already done. Getting them to come back is far easier and far cheaper, if you give them a reason.

1. Reward them the moment they buy

The minute after checkout is when a customer is most excited about your brand. They’ve just made a decision they’re happy with, and they’re looking at your thank you page.

Most stores waste that page on an order number and a “thanks!”. Use it to give customers a reason to come back instead:

  • A discount on their next order
  • Store credit, added straight to their account
  • A free product with their next purchase

Something like “Thanks for your order! Here’s $10 off your next one” turns a one-time buyer into someone with a reason to return.

2. Give them a deadline that brings them back for the holidays

A reward with no end date is easy to forget. Give it a short redeem-by date that lines up with the next reason to shop.

A Black Friday customer who gets “$15 off your next order, valid until December 15” now has a reason to come back for their holiday gifts, and to buy from you instead of searching somewhere else.

Then send a friendly reminder before it expires. A well-timed email often brings back customers who’d otherwise forget.

3. Ask for a review once their order arrives

Reviews are the most convincing thing on your product pages, and after BFCM you’ll have more new customers than at any other time of year.

The timing matters. Ask too soon and they haven’t tried the product yet. Ask once the order has arrived, and offer a small thank-you for their time. Customers are far more likely to share their thoughts when there’s something in it for them.

Ask for a review of each product they bought, not just the order as a whole. That way every product page builds up its own reviews.

4. Turn your new customers into content

Every BFCM order is a potential photo, unboxing or post. Real customers showing off your products sell better than any ad you could make, and they’re exactly what you need for your December campaigns.

Reward customers for sharing a photo or tagging you on Instagram or TikTok. You build a library of real customer content, and they get a reason to shop with you again.

5. Raise order value while they’re already shopping

During a sale, shoppers are in the mood to buy. Show them what they’ll earn if they add a little more:

  • “Spend $50 more to earn $25 off your next order.”

Spend tiers in the cart do two things at once: they make the current order bigger, and they give the customer a reward that brings them back for the next one.

6. Measure what comes back

Don’t wait until January to wonder whether it worked. Track:

  • How many rewards you gave out
  • How many customers came back to use them
  • How much revenue those return orders brought in

Those numbers tell you what your BFCM customers are really worth, beyond their first order.

Your Black Friday retention checklist

Before the sale starts:

  • Put a reward for the next order on your thank you page
  • Set a redeem-by date that brings customers back before the holidays
  • Plan a reminder email before rewards expire
  • Ask for product reviews once orders arrive
  • Reward customers for sharing photos and posts
  • Add spend tiers to your cart
  • Decide how you’ll track repeat orders

Make BFCM the start, not the end

You’re going to spend a lot to win new customers this Black Friday. Make sure it’s the start of a relationship, not a one-off sale.

We built Post Perks to do all of this inside Shopify: rewards on your thank you and order status pages, spend tiers in the cart, product reviews, and social posts, with Reward Activity showing you the revenue that comes back. It takes an afternoon to set up, with no code.

Try Post Perks free →

Liz ChanCo-founder of Uppercase, the team behind Post Perks: the Shopify app that turns first-time buyers into repeat customers.